In the U.S. version of The Grandmaster (the latest movie about Ip Man) they cut the movie from 130 minutes (original Chinese version) down to 108 minutes for the U.S. market.
Did they do it justice or chop it to pieces?
I was expecting to be disappointed, but instead I was pleasantly surprised!
I really liked this movie! And I'm not just saying so because I train Wing Chun and biased. (The grandmaster in this movie is Ip Man and he's one of the important figures in Wing Chun kung fu.)
If you read my review of the Chinese version of The Grandmaster, you know I didn't hold back any punches. I felt let down.
But the U.S. version seemed to fix everything I felt was wrong about the original Chinese cut.
Maybe the Weinstein Co. (who bought the U.S. rights to the movie) or Wong Kar Wai read my review and listened ;-)
You'll enjoy it, whether or not you're a martial arts movie fan, kung fu artist, or Wing Chun fighter.
A friend, who does not practice Wing Chun or any martial arts, but who also watched the Chinese and U.S. versions, also liked the American cut a lot more!
Plus, this movie is so good you can take a date to it. Really.
Yes, you and your date will enjoy the butt kicking, great cinematography (which director Wong Kar Wai is known for), a stronger story (or better told story), a bit of frustrated romance, and butt kicking (did I say that already?)
[No spoilers] This movie is 'inspired' by Ip Man's life.
There's a love story, which
probably didn't happen in real life. But all the major events taking place
around him did occur: a Japanese invasion, losing his family fortune, getting challenged to fight and prove his martial arts skill, moving to Hong Kong, starting a Wing Chun school to make money.
The overall story is the kung fu master from the North is retiring. He visits the South to say his good-byes and hand over the grandmaster-ship to his chosen heir.
Since they're all martial artists, they naturally start challenge matches. (You got to love that plot)
This leads directly to Ip Man meeting and touching hands with dozens of kung fu masters from all kinds of styles from all over China. Tai chi, Ba ji, Xing Yi, Bagua, Hung Gar, and more. It's so much fun!
Because of all these kung fu bad asses, the original English translation for the movie was 'The Grandmaster-s' (with an s, for plural).
What happened was director Wong Kar Wai spent about 8 years researching and preparing for this movie. In the process, he interviewed dozens of kung fu masters and fell in love with kung fu.
He wanted this movie to demonstrate all the different kinds of kung fu. And it does it very well!
For the U.S. version they really drilled down on the probably fictional love story, while bringing in all the other elements: various kung fu grandmasters, Japanese invasion, moving to Hong Kong, starting a Wing Chun school, etc.
The story flowed well.
They cut the original film from 130 minutes to 108 minutes. However, what's interesting is besides taking out what's not needed, they added new footage to tell the story better.
Plus, they reorganized the whole concept of one of the characters - Razor - which was a real pet-peeve of mine in the Chinese version.
But don't worry if you haven't seen the original version. I just mention this in case you read my previous review. You won't be able to tell any of this on your own. You'll just have a great time.
This movie appeals to many different people, at different levels, for different reasons.
There's a little something for everyone: action, high brow art, plenty of eye candy for cinematography buffs, a love story, a villain, honor, sacrifice, heroes, revenge...
Go see it and tell us what you think below.
Other Kung Fu/Wing Chun Movies You'll Enjoy:
Search This Site
Great Wing Chun Kung Fu Gear
Αpply Wing Chun Kung Fu – Chinese Boxing – Street Fighting The first school of martial arts to announce and spread Wing Chun Kung Fu in Greece, founded
I have practiced Goju for about 10 years, and about 6 months ago started learning aikido for a change of pace, but I have ALWAYS wanted to learn Wing Chun.
18 incredible gifts to get the Wing Chun'er this holiday season.