Is it advisable to study Wing Chun over a long period of time under different lineages and or sifus?

I know this is probably a stupid question because honestly I can already sort of predict the answer (which is no), but I'm in a bit of a dilemma right now and I need help.

I intend to study Wing Chun over a very long time (which means I actually intend to master it) as a form of health therapy (I suffer from epilepsy, GERD, scoliosis, costochondritis, and depression.) but I am always on the move. I tend to travel from one country to another (currently I circulate among 3 countries), and as of now, it really can't helped. There's no way I can stay put in one area.

I plan on continuing my learning wherever I currently am, but the problem with it is, you might say, the availability of sifus. Say, for example, in Area 1, I can only find a Duncan Leung lineage sifu. In Area 2, only a Wong Sheung Leung lineage sifu. And in the last one, Area 3, only a Chu Sau Lei Wing Chun sifu. Is it all right if I learn Wing Chun that way? Under different sifus, Wing Chun styles? Or will it only confuse me or be troublesome later on?

Because if that's the case, I guess I'm gonna have to switch to a different martial art for my health therapy. ^^; Something consistent in every area, I guess. Maybe Tae Kwon Do.

Thanks in advance!
Comment/Answer: Hi, I would say in general one should get good or solid in one area before moving to another new one.

Building mastery or even proficiency is a matter of time. How many hours did you "do". Wing Chun, piano, sketching, writing, swimming, cooking, arithmetic, spent in the operating room, you name it.

It's also important to mention that the "doing" has to be correct or self-correcting. In other words, perfect practice makes perfect.

But everyone's situation is different and unique.

I'm biased, so I'd prefer you learn from different Wing Chun lineages than a different martial art. The decision is yours.

However, those Wing Chun families sound great and you're lucky that you'll be close to them during your travels.

I'd say go for it.

One trick you can try is to compartmentalize each lineage in your brain as a "separate" martial art - Wing Chun art. Kind of like you would do if you did start taking TKD classes.

For instance, if you could turn your brain into a computer file, you'd have a Wing Chun folder and each lineage under it as a sub-folder.

Just take the right one out when you're in class and training... and lock in the new information into the right one.

I hope this kind of brain hack can help you avoid some of the initial confusion; until you build enough proficiency in the lineages and can adapt or meld them into your own unique way.

P.S. One more thing. I've had numerous chances to take some Wing Chun classes from other schools, but shied away each time because I was afraid I'd muddy my technique. Maybe I would have, but I do regret walking away from touching hands with other lineages. If I was in your shoes, I would go ahead and study under those different Wing Chun schools.

Comments for Is it advisable to study Wing Chun over a long period of time under different lineages and or sifus?

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Apr 18, 2013
Training under different Wing Chun lineages
by: SIFU Michael Mcilwrath

I agree. You should touch hands with as many people as possible. It does not matter the lineages, style or level. The more the better. You will improve much faster by doing so. And you will know right away how you stack up and what you need to work on.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Wing Chun Kung Fu Questions?.

Search This Site

Great Wing Chun Kung Fu Gear

Recent Articles

  1. She Was Young, Beautiful, And Murdered...

    One night, I get a call from my buddy. Long story short. This girl and her friend were kidnapped and tied up.

    Read More

  2. Your Safety Is Your Responsibility.

    A few years ago we took a trip to Zion National Park in the state of Utah. Every park ranger we ran into or led us on a tour told us, "your safety is your responsibility."

    Read More

  3. Do you ever fear walking in your neighborhood?

    I used to live in a relatively safe community. It's still safer than other areas of Los Angeles, but

    Read More